D Star
Well yesterday Hannah and myself saw a presentation of D Star radio. I have to say at first I was quite impressed. The routing systems were weird, and the system seemed to be fairly open. And both Kenwood and Icom were using it (though as it seems all that Kenwood does is rebadge icom dstar radios for the japanese market.)
The data modes on 23 centemetres (1.2GHz) were amazing, 128kbps while slow to us with our fast broadband connections, was very fast for radio based data modes.
But upon looking into it further is that the codec used for the audio modes is the AMBE codec. This is the bad part, while the whole dstar standard is open, the codec used for audio is propriatory and the licensing fees for the codec are insane.
It just doesn’t feel like amateur radio when the main part of the radio system that being the voice mode, is not open. Amateurs have gone from AM voice to SSB to various digital modes like psk31 all of which are open protocols, where the AMBE codec is closed.